Upside-Linked Deal Design
Trade some guaranteed pay for a clearly measured share of created value
- Difficulty
- Advanced
- Time to result
- ~weeks to results
- Steps
- 6
- Confidence
- 98%
Start with the value the work is expected to influence and record the current baseline before any intervention. Negotiate enough guaranteed cash to cover the minimum acceptable compensation, then link additional pay to performance above the baseline. Define the metric, measurement source, attribution window, percentage, cap, payment schedule, and what happens when external factors distort the result. Equity or options can create much larger upside, but they also add dilution, valuation, tax, vesting, liquidity, and total-loss risk. The host's biotechnology outcome is an exceptional anecdote, not a normal expected return. The framework aligns incentives only when both parties can inspect the same result and the worker has meaningful influence over it.
Origin
Extracted from The Diary of a CEO
Core principles
- 01Compensation structure can matter as much as the headline fee
- 02Upside should be linked to measurable value created
- 03A base payment can protect minimum needs
- 04Baseline performance must be defined before work begins
- 05Risk, liquidity, control, and downside differ across cash, commission, options, and equity
How to run it
- 1
Define created value
Identify the revenue, savings, investment, or other result the work can materially influence.
Pro tip Choose one primary outcome that both parties can observe.
Watch out Do not promise control over outcomes driven mainly by market conditions or other teams.
- 2
Lock the baseline
Agree the current performance level, data source, and measurement period before the work starts.
Pro tip Use an average when one month would be unusually noisy.
- 3
Protect the floor
Set the guaranteed cash payment needed to make the work viable if no upside is earned.
Pro tip Price the floor against time, costs, and financial obligations.
Watch out A token base can shift excessive business risk onto the worker.
- 4
Specify the upside
Define the percentage or award earned above the agreed trigger, including the term, cap, and payment timing.
Pro tip Model low, expected, and high outcomes before signing.
Watch out Ambiguous attribution invites disputes after value has been created.
- 5
Price non-cash risk
For equity or options, assess vesting, dilution, strike price, tax, control, liquidity, and the possibility of receiving nothing.
Pro tip Use qualified legal and tax advice for material equity compensation.
Watch out A headline share count has no reliable value without the full terms and company outcome.
- 6
Document verification
Put access to data, calculation rules, audit rights, and payment mechanics in writing.
Pro tip Run a sample calculation using historical data before agreeing.
In the wild
The guest suggests accepting part of a proposed salary as guaranteed cash and requesting a percentage of funnel revenue above the company's existing monthly baseline. The example makes incremental value, rather than total revenue, the trigger.
→ Compensation rises only when the agreed metric exceeds its starting level.
The host says he received options while helping a biotechnology company build its marketing team and later saw a very large paper gain after the company listed. He presents the deal structure as transformative, but the episode does not establish that such an outcome is typical or repeatable.
→ Non-cash upside reportedly outweighed what a fixed six-month fee might have paid.
Common mistakes
Sharing total revenue
Without a baseline, compensation can be disconnected from the incremental value the work produced.
Treating equity as cash
Options or shares can be diluted, illiquid, taxed, or worthless and should not be valued like guaranteed payment.
Leaving attribution vague
Multiple channels and teams can influence an outcome, so measurement and credit rules must be agreed in advance.
Is it for you?
Best for
It is best for work with a clear baseline, attributable results, transparent reporting, and parties able to bear variable outcomes.
Not ideal for
It is not ideal when results cannot be attributed, the worker needs predictable income, or equity terms and legal risks are not understood.
From the transcript
“can I have a percentage of The Upside”
“an extra 10% of everything I drive above your 100K”
From the episode
The Top 7 Money Making Hacks For 2025 That Are PROVEN To Work! Do Not Buy A House! Do This Instead!